The Star of the Sea schools were started by the Marist Community and the Sisters of Notre Dame in 1959. Today, Star of the Sea includes a middle school, an elementary school and an early learning center. The high school has closed.
Sisters who taught or administered in the school include:
- Carolyn Buhs (Mary Charles), 1968-1972
- Marie Annette Burkart, 1966-1969, 1972-1974
- Frances Charlton (Francis Marie), 1967-1970
- Janet Marie Egan, 1965-1967
- Barbara Hanagan (Raymond Teresa), 1970-1974
- Denis Marie Harney, 1959-1967
- Lucy Holguin (Lucy Julie), 1976-1984
- Mary Ellen Howard (Mary Ignatius), 1967-1972
- Carol Kenning (Mary Matthew), 1967-1968
- Ann Maureen King, 1967-1970
- Jacinta Martinez (Mary Jacinta), 1976-1977
- Noreen Morgan (Valerie), 1970-1975
- Agnes Jerome Murphy, 1950-1963
- Cecile Elizabeth Nagle, 1970-1973
- Peggy Offley (Robert), 1962-1967
- Mary Florence O’Rourke, 1976-1977
- Celeste Pagliarulo (Marie Celeste), 1972-1976
- Karen Pozniak (Evelyn Marie), 1973-1977
- Sharon Skain (Mary Fidelis), 1970-1973
- Barbara Thiella (Andrea), 1970-1972
- Winifred Wall (Mary Winifred), 1957-1968